A Guide for the students of degrees in English Literature/Language. The contents are a compilation of lecture notes taken while studying as a student at the Fatima Jinnah Women University, Rwp, Pakistan. Note: The contents of the blog are meant as a guide for those studying relative material, therefore it is advised against copying, quoting or referring to the blog in official reports, documents and assignments. Plagiarism is a serious crime in the academic world. (Moneeza Rafiq)
Saturday, 2 February 2013
Fourteen: 'The Falling Girl' by Dino Buzzati
Dino
Buzzati
Dino
Buzzati was a master fantasist of the twentieth century who is famous
in Italian Literature. His specialty is that he combines realism with
fantasy.
~The
Falling Girl~
The
text of the story is given below:
NOTES
Thirteen: 'The Revolver' by Emilia Pardo Bazan
Emilia
Pardo Bazan
(1857-1921)
Spain
Although
not widely known in the United States, Emilia Pardo Bazan is a
central and influential figure in nineteenth-century Spanish
literature, the author of more than twenty novels as well as a number
of short stories and critical essays on literary and other subjects.
The only child of titled Spanish royalty, Pardo Bazan inherited the
title of Countess. Yet despite her aristocratic background, her
political views were scarcely traditional. An early feminist, she
expressed in a variety of writings her profound objections to the
oppressive conditions for women in Spanish society. Her fiction is in
the tradition of the naturalism practiced by her French counterparts,
Emile Zola and Gustave Flaubert, although Pardo Bazan distinguished
Spanish naturalism as less deterministic than that of her French
contemporaries.
'The
Revolver' first appeared in a Spanish newspaper.
~The
Revolver~
In
a burst of confidence, one of those provoked by the familiarity and
companionship of bathing resorts, the woman suffering from heart
trouble told me about her illness, with all the details of chokings,
violent palpitations, dizziness, fainting spells, and collapses, in
which one sees the final hour approach... As she spoke, I looked her
over carefully. She was a woman of about thirty-five or thirty-six,
maimed by suffering at least I thought so, but, on close scrutiny, I
began to suspect that there was something more than the physical in
her ruin. As a matter of fact, she spoke and expressed herself like
someone who had suffered a good deal, and I know that the ills of the
body, when not of imminent gravity, are usually not enough to produce
such a wasting away, such extreme dejection. And, noting how the
broad leaves of the plane tree, touched with carmine by the artistic
hand of autumn, fell to the ground majestically and lay stretched out
like severed hands, I remarked, in order to gain her confidence, on
the passing of all life, the melancholy of the transitoriness of
everything...
“Nothing
is anything,” she answered, understanding at once that not
curiosity but compassion was beckoning at the gates of her spirit.
“Nothing is anything... unless we ourselves convert that nothing
into something. Would to God we could see everything, always, with
the slight but sad emotion produced in us by the fall of this foliage
on the sand.”
The
sickly flush of her cheeks depened, and then I realized that she had
probably been very beautiful, although her beauty was effaced and
gone, like the colors of a fine picture over which is passed cotton
saturated with alcohol. Her blond, silky hair showed traces of ash,
premature gray hair. Her features had withered away; her complexion
especially revealed those disturbances of the blood which are slow
poisonings, decompositions of the organism. Her soft blue eyes,
veined with black, must have once been attractive, but now they were
disfigured by something worse than age, a kind of aberration, which
at certain moments lent them the glitter of blindness.
We
grew silent, but my way of contemplating her expressed my pity so
plainly that she, sighing for a chance to unburden her heavy heart,
made up her mind, and stopping from time to time to breathe and
regain her strength, she told me the strange story.
“When
I was married, I was very much in love... My husband was, compared to
me, advanced in years; he was bordering on forty, and I was only
nineteen. My temperament was gay and lively; I retained a childlike
disposition, and when he was not home I would devote my time to
singing, playing the piano, chatting and laughing with girl-friends
who came to see me and envied me my happiness, my brilliant marriage,
my devoted husband, and my brilliant social position.
“This
lasted a year- the wonderful year of the honeymoon. The following
spring, on our wedding anniversary, I began to notice that Reinaldo's
disposition was changing. He was often in a gloomy mood, and, without
my knowing the cause, he spoke to me harshly, and had outbursts of
anger. But It was not long before I understood the origins of his
transformation. Reinaldo had conceived a violent, irrational
jealousy, a jealousy without objection or cause, which, for that very
reason, was doubly cruel and difficult to cure.
“If
we went out together, he was watchful lest people stare at me or tell
me, in passing, one of those silly things people say to young women;
if he went out alone, he was suspicious of what I was doing in the
house, and of the people who came to see me; if I went out alone, his
suspicions and suppositions were even more defamatory...
“If
I proposed, pleadingly, that we stay home together, he was watchful
of my saddened expression, of my supposed boredom, of my work, of an
instant when, passing in front of the window, I happened to look
outside... He was watchful, above all, when he noticed that my
birdlike disposition, my good, childlike humor, had disappeared, and
that on many afternoons, when I turned on the lights, he found my
skin shining with the damp, ardent traces of tears. Deprived of my
innocent amusement, now separated from my friends and relatives, and
from my own family, because Reinaldo interpreted as treacherous
artifices the desire to communicate and look at faces other than his,
I often wept, and did not respond to Reinaldo's transports of passion
with the sweet abandonment of earlier times.
“One
day, after one of the usual bitter scenes, my husband said:
“
'Flora,
I may be a madman, but I am not a fool. I have alienated your love,
and although perhaps you would not have thought of deceiving me, in
the future, without being able to remedy it, you would. Now I shall
never again be your beloved. The swallows that have left do not
return. But because, unfortunately, I love you more each day, and
love you without peace, with eagerness and fever, I wish to point out
that I have thought of a way which will prevent questions, quarrels,
or tears between us-- and once and for all you will know what our
future will be.'
“Speaking
thus, he took me by the arm and led me toward the bedroom.
“I
went trembling; cruel presentiments froze me. Reinaldo opened the
drawer of the small inlaid cabinet where he kept tobacco, a watch,
and handkerchiefs and showed me a large revolver, a sinister weapon.
“
'Here,'
he said, 'is your guarantee that in the future your life will be
peaceful and pleasant. I shall never again demand an accounting of
how you spend your time, or of your friends, or of your amusements.
You are free, free as the air. But the day I see something that
wounds me to the quick... that day, I swear by my mother! Without
complaints or scenes, or the slightest sign that I am displeased, oh
no, not that! I will get up quietly at night, take the weapon, put
it to your temple and you will wake up in eternity. Now you have been
warned...'
“As
for me, I was in a daze, unconscious. It was necessary to send for
the doctor, in as much as the fainting spell lasted. When I recovered
consciousness and remembered, the convulsion took place. I must point
out that I have a mortal fear of firearms; a young brother of mine
died of an accidental shot. My eyes, staring wildly, would not leave
the drawer of the cabinet that held the revolver.
“I
could not doubt, from Reinaldo's tone and the look on his face, that
he was prepared to carry out his threat, and knowing also how easily
his imagination grew confused, I began to consider myself as dead. As
a matter of fact, Reinaldo kept his promise, and left me complete
mistress of myself, without directing the slightest censure my way,
or showing, even by a look, that he was opposed to anything of my
wishes or disapproved of my actions; but that itself frightened me,
because it indicated the strength and tyranny of a resolute will...
and, victim of a terror which everyday grew more profound, I remained
motionless, not daring to take a step I would always see the steely
reflection of the gun barrel.
“At
night, insomnia kept my eyes open, and I imagined I felt the metallic
cold of a steel circle on my temple; or if I got to sleep, I woke up
startled with palpitations that made my heart seem to leap from my
breast, because I dreamed that an awful report was ripping apart the
bones of my skull and blowing my brains out, dashing them against the
wall... and this lasted four years, four years without a single
peaceful moment, when I never took a step without fearing that that
step might give rise to tragedy.”
“And
how did that horrible situation end?” I asked, in odrer to bring
her story to a close, because I saw her gasping for breath.
“It
ended... with Reinaldo, who was thrown by a horse, and had some
internal injury, being killed on the spot.
“Then,
and only then, I knew that I still loved him, and I mourned him quite
sincerely, although he was my executioner, and a systematic one at
that!”
“And
did you pick up the revolver to throw it out the window?”
“You'll
see,” she murmured. “Something rather extraordinary happened. I
sent Reinaldo's manservant to remove the revolver from my room,
because in my dreams I continued to see the shot and feel the chill
on my temple... and after he carried out the order, the manservant
came to tell me: 'Senora, there was no cause for alarm... this
revolver wasn't loaded.'
“
'No,
Senora, and it looks to me as though it never was... As a matter of
fact, the poor master never got around to buying the cartridges. Why,
I would even ask him at times if he wanted me to go to the gunsmith's
and get them, but he didn't answer, and then he never spoke of the
matter again.'”
“And
so,” added the sufferer from heart disease, “an unloaded revolver
shot me, not in the head, but in the center of my heart, and believe
me when I tell you that, in spite of digitalis and baths and all the
remedies, the bullet is unsparing...”
[1895]
Translated
by
ANGEL
FLORES
NOTES
Few
Important Lines:
- “Nothing is anything,” she answered. “Nothing is anything... unless we ourselves convert that nothing into something.”
- I began to suspect that there was something more than the physical in her ruin. As a matter of fact, she spoke and expressed herself like someone who had suffered a good deal, and I know that the ills of the body, when not of imminent gravity, are usually not enough to produce such a wasting away, such extreme dejection.
- “an unloaded revolver shot me, not in the head, but in the center of my heart, and believe me when I tell you that, in spite of digitalis and baths and all the remedies, the bullet is unsparing...”
Some
Important Points:
The
story is written from first person point of view but the narrator is
the listener and Flora is the one telling her story.
The
lines 'Nothing is anything' suggest that perhaps Flora exaggerated
her situation with her husband and mistook his actions for the worst.
Perhaps her husband was not overly possessive and just a little
concerned and her own imagination led her to believe the worst.
Nothing is the way it seems and we ourselves turn it into something.
Flora's own perceptions are important here.
After
reading the story the readers realize there was a lack of
communication between the couple. Flora loved her husband very much
and her husband loved her back but they never tried to solve their
differences through dialogue and understanding. Flora never seemed to
complain or talk to her husband about his change of behaviour and
Reinaldo too, perhaps never voiced his concerns or doubts about her.
In this way both of them did not get a chance to explain their
actions to the other.
People
are not born bad, but certain situations and their reactions turn
them into bad people. Perhaps Reinaldo was not a cruel and ruthless
possessive lover, but we are unable to be sure because the story is
one-sided. We do not get to hear it from Reinaldo's point of view. We
only understand Flora's doubts, fears and imaginations. There is a
possibility that Flora must have done something to pique Reinaldo's
doubts about her actions. Perhaps she was too liberal and carefree
which was intolerable for a man of Reinaldo's age and disposition.
Therefore, it is not correct to label the two characters on the basis
of this one-sided story.
Trust
is very important in relationships and lack of trust leads to
downfall of even the most sacred bond of marriage.
Nothing
is good if it is in excess. Reinaldo's excess of love for his wife
lead to possessiveness and jealousy. According to Flora, Reinaldo
wished she would look at only his face and alienate herself from
everyone else.
When
something is lost only then one realizes the worth of that thing.
Flora realized how much she was in love with her husband only when he
died. She should have valued his love and taken him into confidence
through her love and trust. It is the characteristic of a good wife
that she considers the likes and dislikes of her husband and tries
not to upset him through her actions. Flora should have considered
Reinaldo's tastes and molded herself accordingly for a harmonious
living. Reinaldo too, should have trusted his wife and tried to
tolerate things which make her happy.
Your
perceptions matter the most in any situation. Both thought that they
were not loved by the other, but in the end it is made clear that
they both loved each other very much. But they did not share their
assumptions. It was very explicit that Reinaldo's threat was an empty
threat, Flora should have realized that if he had not made a move to
harm her in four years he never really meant to hurt her at all. She
should have approached him and talked to him reasonably through
sensible dialogue about their situation. She should have expressed
her mortal fear of firearms and tried to reduce the distance between
them.
Age
could be taken as a factor for the differences between the couple.
Being a teenager Flora's activities and interests were contrary to
those of a forty year old man who has lived his life and gathered
enough experiences to make him a sober individual. Reinaldo should
have known that a woman of Flora's age is bound to have social habits
and he should have given her enough time to mold herself into the
woman he wanted her to be. Flora was too busy carrying on with her
lifestyle to realize that perhaps some of her habits were disliked by
Reinaldo. The lack of understanding and high expectations on both
sides can be attributed to an age barrier.
The
'revolver' is a symbol of fear, danger and killing. From the first
sight of the revolver Flora's inner carefree and birdlike personality
died and fear took its place. The revolver also represents loss; loss
of confidence on part of Flora, loss of love, trust and loss of
desires and dreams. For Flora it was a symbol of death and fear of
death, considering her past experience about the weapon. It was also
the symbol of death of their marriage when Reinaldo died. In the end
it represented an empty threat from Reinaldo as an empty weapon.
Flora lost her health after she was exposed to the weapon by
Reinaldo. She lost her fairness, her youth, her liveliness, her charm
and her beauty. Everything withered away and she slowly became an
ailing woman.
Main
Themes:
- Different facets of love.
- Age Barrier.
- People and their responses to different situations.
- Psychological Analysis of married couples.
- Lack of communication.
- Jealousy and possessiveness.
Questions:
- What is the exact nature of Flora's illness? Why does she continue to suffer?
- How would you describe the relationship between Flora and Reinaldo?
- What is the theme of the story?
- What does the Revolver symbolize in the story?
- How do the images of the story contribute to its tone and theme?Credit-Muneeza Rafiq
Twelve: 'The Gold-Legged Frog' by Khamsing Srinawk
Khamsing
Srinawk
(b.
1930)
THAILAND
Khamsing
Srinawk was born in 1930 in a small village in northeastern Thailand.
Although his family was poor and uneducated, he was encouraged by an
uncle who was a monk to pursue his intellectual interests. Before
pursuing his literary career in earnest, he served as a forest ranger
in northern Thailand and as an assistant to a group of
anthropological researchers in a village near Bangkok. His first
collection of short stories No Barriers, was published in 1958; The
Politician and Other Stories appeared in 1972.
~The
Gold-legged Frog~
The
sun blazed as if determined to crisp every living thing in the broad
fields. Now and again the tall, straight, isolated sabang
and payom
trees let go some of their dirty yellow leaves. He sank exhausted
against a tree trunk with his dark blue shirt wet with sweat. The
expanse around him expressed total dryness. He stared at the tufts of
dull grass and bits of straw spun in a column to the sky. The brown
earth sucked up into the air cast a dark pall over everything. A
whirlwind. He recalled the old people had told him this was the
portent of drought, want, disaster and death, and he was afraid. He
was now anxious to get home; he could see the tips of bamboo thickets
surrounding the house far ahead looking like blades of grass. Bur he
hesitated. A moment before reaching the shade of the tree he felt his
ears buzz and his eyes blur and knew it meant giddiness and
sunstroke. He looked at the soles of his feet blistered from the
burning sandy ground and became indescribably angry – angry with
the weather capable of such endless torture. In the morning the cold
had pierced his bones, but now it was so hot he felt his head would
break into bits and pieces. As he remembered the biting cold of the
morning, he thought again of his little son.
That
same morning he and two of his small children went out into the dry
paddy fields near the house to look for frogs for the morning meal.
The air was so chilly the two children on either side of him shivered
as they stopped to look for frogs hiding in the cracks of the parched
earth. Each time they saw two bright eyes in a deep crack, they would
shout, “Pa, here's another one. Pa, this crack has two. Gold-legged
ones! Hurry, Pa.”
He
dashed from place to place as the voices called him, prying up the
dry clods with his hoe. He caught some of the frogs immediately, but
a few jumped away as soon as he began digging. It was the children's
job to chase and pounce on them. Many got away. Some jumped into
different fissures obliging him to pry up a new cake of earth. If his
luck was good, besides the frog, he would find a land snail or a
razor clam buried waiting for the rains. He would take these as well.
The
air was warming and already he had enough frogs to eat with the
morning rice. The sound of drumming, the village chief's call for a
meeting, sounded faintly from the village. Vauge anger again spilled
over as his thoughts returned to that moment. If only he had gone
home then the poor child would be all right now. It was really the
last crack. As soon as he poked it, the ground broke apart. A fully
grown gold-legged frog as big as a thumb leaped past the bigger
child. The younger raced after it for about twelve yards when it
dodged into the deep hoofprint of a water buffalo. The child groped
after it. And then he was shocked almost senseless by the trembling
cry of his boy, “Pa, a snake, a snake bit my hand.”
A
cobra spread its hood, hissing. When finally able to act, the father
with all his strenght brought the handle of his hoe three times down
on the back of the serpent leaving its tail twitching. He carried his
child and the basket of frogs home without forgetting to tell the
other to drag the snake along as well.
On
the way back his son cried softly and moaned, beating his chest with
his fists and complaining he could not breathe. At home, the father
summoned all the faith-healers and herbalists whose names he could
think of and the turmoil began.
“Chop
up a frog, roast it, and put it on the wound,” a neighbour called
out.
When
another shouted, “Give him the toasted liver of the snake to eat,”
he hurriedly slit open the snake to look for the liver while his wife
sat by crying.
The
later it got, the bigger the crowd. On hearing the news, all the
neighbours attending the village chief's meeting joined the others.
One of them told him he had to go to the District Office in town that
day because the village chief told them it was the day the government
was going to hand out money to those with five or more children, and
he was one who had just five. It was a new shock.
“Can't
you see my boy's gasping out his life? How can I go?”
“What
difference will it make? You've called in a lot of doctors, all of
them expert.”
“Go,
you fool. It's two hundret baht they're giving. You've never had that
much in your life-time. Two hundred!”
“Leave
this for a bit,” another added. “If the boy dies, you'll be out,
that's all.”
“I
won't go,” he yelled. “My child can't breathe and you tell me to
go. Why can't they give it out some other day? It's true I've never
had two hundred baht since I was born, but I'm not going. I'm not
going.”
“Jail,”
another interjected. “If you don't go, you simply go to jail.
Whoever disobeyed the authorities? If they decided to give, you have
to take, if not, jail.”
The
word “jail” repeated like that affected him, but still, he
resisted.
“Whatever
it is, I said I'm not going. I don't want it. How can I leave him
when he's dying?” He raised his voice. “I'm not going.”
“You
go. Don't go against the government. We're subjects.” He turned to
find the village chief standing grimly at his side. His voice dried
up immediately.
“If
I don't go, will it really be jail?” he asked.
“For
sure,” the village chief replied sternly. “Maybe for life.”
That
was all there was to it. Dazed, he asked the faith-healers and
neighbours to take care of his son and left the house.
He
reached the District Office almost at eleven and he found a group of
his neighbours who had also come for the money sitting in a group.
They told him to address the old deputy district officer which he
did.
“I
am Mr. Nark Na-ngarm, sir, I have come for money, the many children
money.”
The
deputy district officer raised his fat face to stare at him for a
moment then spoke heavily. “Idiot, don't you have eyes to see
people are working. Get out! Get out and wait outside.”
“Bur
sir, my child is dying.” But he cut himself short when he thought
perhaps if the official suspected that his child had died there would
be trouble. The deputy officer looked down at his paper and went on
scribbling. Nark dejectedly joined the group outside. “All one does
is suffer, born a rice farmer and a subject,” he thought. “Poor
and helpless, one's mouth stained from eating roots when the rice has
run out, at the end of one's tether, you turn to the authorities only
to be put down.” The official continued to write as if there were
no groups of peasants waiting anxiously. A few minutes after twelve,
he strode from the office but had the kindness to say a few words.
“It's
noon already. Time for a break. Come back at one o'clock for it.”
Nark
and his neighbours sat there waiting till one o'clock. The taciturn
deputy on returning called them all to sit on the floor near him. He
began by asking each of them why they had so many children. The
awkward replies of the peasant brought guffaws from the other
officials who turned to listen to the embarrassing answers. At last
it had to be his turn.
“Who
is Mr. Nark Na-ngarm?”
“I
am, sir,” he responded with humility.
“And
now why do we have such a lot of children?”
Several
people tittered.
“Oh,
when you're poor, sir...,” he burst out, his exasperation
uncontrollable.
“What
the hell's it got to do with being poor?” the deputy officer
questioned in a voice that showed disappointment with the answer.
“So
poor and no money to buy a blanket. The kids just keep coming.”
Instead
of laughter, dead silence, finally broken by the dry voice of the
blank-faced deputy, “Bah! This joker uses his wife for a blanket.”
The
wind gusted again. The sabang
and payom
trees threw off a lot of leaves. The spears of sunlight still dazzled
him. The whirlwind still hummed in the middle of the empty ricefield
ahead. Nark left the shade of the tall tree and went through the
flaming afternoon sunshine heading for his village.
“Hey,
Nark...” The voice came from a group of villagers still some
distance away. It was topped by another.
“You
sure are lucky.” The words raised his spirits. He smiled a little
before repeating expectantly, “How was I lucky, how?”
“The
two hundred baht. You got it, didn't you?”
“I
got it. It's right here.” He patted his pocket.
“What
luck! You sure have good luck, Nark. One more day and you'd have been
out by two hundred baht.”
[1958]
Translated
by
DOMNERN
GARDEN
NOTES
Meanings
of Difficult Words:
- Expanse: a wide, continuous area.
- Portent: a sign of warning that a momentous or calamitous even is likely to happen.
- Want: lack or be short of something essential.
- Thickets: a dense group of bushes or trees.
- Pry: enquire.
- Fissure: a long narrow crack.
- Hoe: a long-handled gardening tool with a thin metal blade, used mainly for weeding.
- Baht: monetary unit of Thailand.
- Dejected: sad or dispirited.
- Taciturn: reserved or uncommunicative in speech, saying little.
- Guffaw: a loud and hearty laugh.
Few
Important Lines:
- Whoever disobeyed the authorities? If they decide to give, you have to take, if not, jail.
- “All one does is suffer, born a rice farmer and a subject,” he thought, “Poor and helpless, one's mouth stained from eating roots when the rice has run out, at the end of one's tether, you turn to the authorities only to be put down.”
- “What luck! You sure have good luck, Nark. One more day and you'd have been out by two hundred baht.”
Important
Points:
This
story has a third-person perspective. The main character of the story
is Nark, a rice farmer with five children and a poor economic status.
He is a man who is helpless not because he is poor but because he
does not have any authority and no representation. Poor people
struggle very hard, just as Nark is shown working hard to get
breakfast in the paddy fields. For them, survival is important. There
are many ideas of superstitous belief and faiths in the village where
Nark lives. It is a backward society, where ignorance about health,
law and value of life is conspicuous.
It
is a very hard life for the rice farmers, as an agricultural job
requires dependence upon water, environment, seasons and proper
growth of plantations. If there is a drought then there is nothing
the farmers can do, and they become helpless. They run out of food
and money.
Nark
is maltreated by the authorities. The rich seem to have the authority
to exploit, ridicule and mock the poor people. There writer is trying
to highlight how the poor are manipulated, insulted and mentally
tortured by those in power.
If
the authorities have decided to help the poor then they are doing it
in the worst possible way, they are making the poor lose their
dignity and respect in order to get what they deserve. It is an act
of cruelty and sadism.
The
word “luck” used in the end of the story is ironic and
paradoxical because it is luck that Nark got the money, but it was
not actually good luck for him that he lost his son whom he loved
very much.
For
a poor rice farmer, suffering is not merely lack of money and lack of
food in a hot season, it is the way they are treated by the people
that adds to this misery.
“Money
is not required to buy one necessity, of the soul.” - Thoreau.
The
value of human life is shown in the story, when one is poor one is
reduced to prioritizing money over life.
The
gold-legged frog turned out to be a symbol of bad luck instead of
good luck for Nark because it led to the death of his son.
Life
is unpredictable, you can never judge what will happen next. Nark was
not petty or shallow like the District Officer, he was the one who
had a broad vision and who had more patience and tolerance, he was
humbler and more respectful, therefore, one can say that Nark was
metaphorically rich, and the Officer was poor.
Nark’s
good luck:
He
found a fully grown gold-legged frog.
Sometimes
he found a land snail or a razor clam.
He
had a snake to eat.
He
had five children, so he was entitled to the 200 baht.
He
got the money before his son died.
Nark’s
bad luck:
His
son was bitten by a snake when he chased the frog.
He
had many children, because he was poor.
He
lost his son.
Links
are given for further analysis:
Main
Themes:
- Suffering
- Poverty
- Corrupt Leadership
- Father/Son Relationship
- Luck and Misfortune
- Abuse of Power
- Conflict of Wealthy and Poor
- Role of Parents
- Limited Choices
Questions:
- What is the conflict in the story? How does it reveal Nark's economic position and the limits of his choices?
- In what way is the ending of the story ironic? How is “luck” defined?
- How does the detailed descriptions of the setting contribute to your understanding of the exigencies of poverty faced by Nark's family and their neighbours?
Credit-Muneeza Rafiq
Eleven: 'The Street-Sweeping Show' by Feng Jicai
Feng
Jicai
(b.
1942)
CHINA
Feng
Jicai, born in Tianjin, China, began his first career as a painter
but shifted to fiction when his “counter-revolutionary” art was
unwelcome during China's Revolution of the 1960's and 1970's. For the
same reasons, he could not publish his fiction until after the death
of Mao Zedong in 1976. Now a prolific writer (though not yet widely
translated), he currently resides in Tianjin with his wife and son
and holds major positions in Chinese writers' professional
organizations.
Feng
still precipitates controversy with his writing, however. His
translator, Susan Wilff Chen has noted that 'The Street-Sweeping
Show', originally published in 1982, is not reprinted in any of
Feng's collections of short stories, because it resembled a real-life
incident so closely that it caused objections when it first appeared.
~The
Street-Sweeping Show~
“National
Cleanup Week starts today,” said Secretary Zhao, “and officials
everywhere are going out to join in the street sweeping. Here's our
list of participants-- all top city administrators and public
figures. We've just had it mimeographed over at the office for your
approval.”
He
looked like a typical upper-echelon secretary; the collar of his
well-worn, neatly pressed Mao suit was buttoned up military style;
his complexion was pale; his glasses utilitarian. His gentle,
deferential manner and pleasantly modulated voice concealed a shrewd,
hard-driving personality.
The
mayor pored over the list, as if the eighty names on it were those of
people selected to go abroad. From time to time he glanced
thoughtfully at the high white ceiling.
“Why
isn't there anyone from the Women's Federation?” he asked.
Secretary
Zhao thought for a moment. “Oh, you're right-- there isn't! We've
got the heads of every office in the city-- the Athletic Committee,
the Youth League Committee, the Federation of Trade Unions, the
Federation of Literary and Art Circles-- even some famous university
professors. The only group we forgot is the Women's Federation.”
“Women
are the pillars of society. How can we leave out the women's
representatives?” The mayor sounded smug rather than reproachful.
Only a leader could think of everything. This was where true
leadership ability came into play.
Secretary
Zhao was reminded of the time when the mayor had pointed out that the
fish course was missing from the menu of a banquet in honor of some
foreign guests.
“Add
two names from the Women's Federation, and make sure you get people
in the positions of authority or who are proper representatives of
the organization. 'International Working Women's Red Banner
Pacesetters', 'Families of Martyrs' or 'Model Workers' could be
fine.” Like an elementary school teacher returning a poor homework
paper to his student, the mayor handed the incomplete list back to
his secretary.
“Yes,
your honor, I'll do it right away. A complete list will be useful the
next time something like this comes up. And I must contact everyone
at once. The street sweeping is scheduled for two this afternoon in
Central Square. Will you be able to go?”
“Of
course. As mayor of the city, I have to set an example.”
“The
car will be at the gate for you at one-thirty. I'll go with you.”
“All
right,” the mayor answered absentmindedly, scratching his forehead
and looking away.
Secretary
Zhao hurried out.
At
one-thirty that afternoon the mayor was whisked to the square in his
limousine. All office workers, shop clerks, students, housewives, and
retirees were out sweeping the streets, and the air was thick with
dust. Secretary Zhao hastily rolled up the window. Inside the car
there was only a faint, pleasant smell of gasoline and leather.
At
the square they pulled up beside a colorful assortment of limousines.
In front of them a group of top city administrators had gathered to
wait for the mayor's arrival. Someone had arranged for uniformed
policemen to stand guard on all sides.
Secretary
Zhao sprang out of the limousine and opened the door for his boss.
The officials in the waiting crowd stepped forward with smiling faces
to greet the mayor. Everyone knew him and hoped to be the first to
shake his hand.
“Good
afternoon-- oh, nice to see you--- good afternoon---” the mayor
repeated as he shook hands with each of them.
An
old policeman approached, followed by two younger ones pushing
wheel-barrows full of big bamboo brooms. The old policeman selected
one of the smaller, neater brooms and presented it respectfully to
the mayor. When the other dignitaries had gotten their brooms, a
marshal with a red armband led them all to the center of the square.
Naturally the mayor walked at the head.
Groups
of people had come from their workplaces to sweep the huge square. At
the sight of this majestic, broom-carrying procession, with its
marshal, police escort, and retinue of shutter-clicking
photographers, they realized that they were in the presence of no
ordinary mortals and gathered closer for a look. How extraordinary
for a mayor to be sweeping the streets, thought Secretary Zhao,
swelling with unconscious pride as he strutted along beside the mayor
with his broom on his shoulder.
“Here
we are,” the marshal said when they had reached the designated
spot.
All
eighty-two dignitaries began to sweep.
The
swelling crowd of onlookers, which was kept back by a police cordon,
was buzzing with excitement:
“Look,
he's the one over there.”
“Which
one? The one in black?”
“No.
The bald fat one in blue.”
“Cut
the chitchat!” barked a policeman,
The
square was so huge that no one knew where to sweep. The concrete
pavement was clean to begin with; they pushed what little grit there
was back and forth with their big brooms. The most conspicuous piece
of litter was a solitary popsicle wrapper, which they all pursued
like children chasing a dragonfly.
The
photographers surrounded the mayor. Some got down on one knee to
shoot from below, while others ran from side to side trying to get a
profile. Like a cloud in a thunderstorm, the mayor was constantly
illuminated by silvery flashes. Then a man in a visored cap, with a
video camera, approached Secretary Zhao.
“I'm
from the TV station,” he said. “Would you please ask them to line
up single file so they'll look neat on camera?”
Secretary
Zhao consulted with the mayor, who agreed with this request. The
dignitaries formed a long line and began to wield their brooms for
the camera, regardless of whether there was any dirt on the ground.
The
cameraman was about to start shooting, when he stopped and ran over
to the mayor.
“I'm
sorry, your honor,” he said, “but you're all going to have to
face the other way because you've got your backs to the sun. And I'd
also like the entire line to be reversed so that you're at the head.”
“All
right,” the mayor agreed graciously, and he led his entourage, like
a line of dragon dancers, in a clumsy turn-around. Once in place,
everyone began sweeping again.
Pleased,
the cameraman ran to the head of the line, pushed his cap up, and
aimed at the mayor. “All right,” he said as the camera started to
whir, “swing those brooms, all together now-- put your hearts into
it-- that's it! Chin up please, your honor. Hold it-- that's fine--
all right!”
He
stopped the camera, shook the mayor's hand, and thanked him for
helping an ordinary reporter carry out his assignment.
“Let's
call it a day,” the marshal said to secretary Zhao. Then he
returned to the mayor. “You have victoriously accomplished your
mission,” he said.
“Very
good-- thank you for your trouble,” the mayor replied routinely,
smiling and shaking hands again.
Some
reporters came running up to the mayor. “Do you have any
instructions, your honor?” asked a tall, thin, aggressive one.
“Nothing
in particular.” The mayor paused for a moment. “Everyone should
pitch in to clean up our city.”
The
reporters scribbled his precious words in their notebooks.
The
policeman brought the wheel-barrows back, and everyone returned their
brooms. Secretary Zhao replaced the mayor's for him.
It
was time to go. The mayor shook hands with everyone again.
“Good-bye--
good-bye-- good-bye--”
The
others waited until the mayor had gotten into his limousine before
getting into theirs.
The
mayor's limousine delivered him to his house, where his servant had
drawn his bathwater and set out scented soap and fresh towels. He
enjoyed a leisurely bath and emerged from the bathroom with rosy skin
and clean clothes, leaving his grime and exhaustion behind him in the
tub.
As
he descended the stairs to eat dinner, his grandson hurriedly led him
into the living room.
“Look,
Granddad, you're on TV!”
There
he was on the television screen, like an actor, putting on a show of
sweeping the street. He turned away and gave his grandson a casual
pat on the shoulder.
“It's
not worth watching. Let's go have dinner.”
[1982]
Translated
by
SUSAN
WILFF CHEN
NOTES
Meanings
of Difficult Words:
- Echelon: a level of rank in profession.
- Utilitarian:
- Deferential: respectful.
- Reproachful: disapproval.
- Mao: Mao ZeDong (also transliterated as Mao Tse-Tung) (1893-1976) Communist leader and chairman of the Communist party of the People's Republic of Chine from 1949 until his death. Mao led the cultural revolution, 1966 to 1976, including the institution of a uniform code of dress.
Few
Important Lines:
- How extraordinary for a mayor to be sweeping the streets, thought Secretary Zhao, swelling with unconscious pride as he strutted along beside the mayor with his broom on his shoulder.
- He stopped the camera, shook the mayor's hand, and thanked him for helping an ordinary reporter carry out his assignment.
- “Everyone should pitch in to clean up our city.”
- There he was on the television screen, like an actor, putting on a show of sweeping the street. There he was on the television screen, like an actor, putting on a show of sweeping the street.
Important
Points:
“Nothing
is politically right which is morally wrong.” - Daniel O' Connell.
“Absolute
power corrupts absolutely.” - George Orwell.
There
is a theme of 'class distinction' in the story. The government wanted
to spread the message of cleanliness. The people in power have the
authority to influence the society for better or for worse. So the
readers start to admire the mayor for arranging this event and paying
such attention to cleanliness of the city. However, as the readers
continue to read further, they realize that it was just a mind game
and a show to fool the public. The feelings the readers had about the
mayor have now been reversed and his image has been shattered.
Self-appraisal was the main purpose of the mayor. All that mattered
was putting up a show and making people think you are different than
other leaders.
We
can compare the themes of “The Chief Guest” by Akhtar Jamal in
this regard. The focus was on importance of beauty and power. The
psychology of the powerful people is shown in this story. In “The
Chief Guest” the ordinary people wished to be associated with the
powerful people for their own gains. But here, the mayor is
controlling the innocent people. The ideology is to control the
masses so that they never challenge the authorities. We are deceived
by the government. The mayor is exploiting his position and status to
fool the people.
Irony
of the story is that the place did not need any cleaning where the
mayor and his dignitaries were sweeping. Another irony is the last
line of the story said by the mayor, that it was not worth watching.
The mayor himself knows that he is not worth watching, but the public
is unaware.
We
can associate with this story, we feel as if we are similar to the
masses shown in the story. The purpose of the story is to make
people realize what their response should be to such people and how
they should act in such a scenario. The mayor simply wanted to create
an image of himself of a leader who is like the common people, the
civilians, that he is no different than them.
There
is a tug-of-war between the powerful and the powerless. People who
are in power have an agenda, they only want to dominate and remain on
the top, and the powerless become united to overthrow the powerful
and change the dominance status in their favor. This is what brings
revolutions in great nations. Power is simply a tool in the hands of
the powerful. It becomes a controlling factor. It is a phenomenon
that changes people. But the masses always have the strength of
number. We civilians are being exploited at every level, be it
social, economic, political or emotional.
The
story is coaxing the readers to think that what should be their
response? Do they need to challenge such a leader, raise their voices
against him? Or simply create awareness and realize what is happening
around them to make a better and keen decision in the future?
This
story has a universal appeal because it touches an issue that happens
everywhere and is becoming commonplace every day. We need to
understand why this is happening.
The
Role of Media:
The mayor was projected just the way he wanted it to be. Photographer
was simply grinding his own axe. The media is a powerful tool that
changes and shapes our ideas, it shows the agendas of the
authorities. The whole show had been photographed for the public to
see, media did not show the truth. They are supporting and projecting
the same idea of power. Media can be compared to the people in “The
Chief Guest” who wished to invite the former student.
A
link is given for further analysis:
Questions:
- What is the actual purpose of the street-sweeping ceremony?
- What does the story suggest about the public rituals? About bureaucracy? About the media's role in such rituals? Compare this story with Isabel Allende's “And of Clay We Are Created.”
- What is the significance of the title?
- Why does the mayor refuse to watch the ceremony on television?
Credit-Muneeza Rafiq
Ten: 'Half a Day' by Naguib Mahfouz
~Half
a Day~
Naguib
Mahfouz
(b.
1911)
EGYPT
Naguib
Mahfouz was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1988. He was
the first Arab writer to win the prestigious award and only the
second from the African continent. A prolific writer, by the time of
the Nobel Prize Mahfouz had written nearly 25 novels and a dozen
volumes of short stories, in addition to several plays and
screenplays.
The
text of the story is given here:
NOTES
Meanings
of Difficult Words:
- Tarboosh: a tassled cap often worn by Muslim men and made from felt or cloth.
- Unmarred: good, acceptable.
- Fortress: stronghold, barrier.
- Intricate: complicated, elaborate.
- Vaulting: jumping over, springing.
- Exertion: hard work, labour.
- Perseverance: diligence, hard work.
- Gallantly: bravely, courageously.
Few
Important Lines:
- Living beings were drawn to other living beings.
- Dust-laden winds and unexpected accidents came about suddenly, so we had to be watchful, at the ready, and very patient.
- Good Lord! Where was the street lined with gardens? Where had it disappeared to? When did all these vehicles invade it? And when did all these hordes of humanity come to rest upon its surface?
- “Let the fire take its pleasure in what it consumes.”
Important
Points:
The
story has no proper plot layout, simply certain ideas are discussed
and theme is given importance. Naguib Mahfouz is famous for these
kinds of plots. The story is about the general life of a person,
about good and evil, human biasness and weaknesses. Climax of the
story occurs when the readers realize that the narrator is no longer
a boy, but a grown man. There is a time shift in the story.
Different stages of a man's life are shown, from innocence to
maturity.
There
are several symbols used in the story and it is important to explain
them. The title
of the story itself is ironic, it is meant to suggest half a day of
school but the story does not simply cover 'half a day', it covers
the whole lifetime of the narrator. Time is relative, it does not
actually pass quickly, it only seems that way. A good comparison for
the passing of time would be from Shakespeare's Sonnet 60. The Gate
of the school building represents a barrier or a shift from the
garden of paradise to hell, a shift from innocence of childhood to
the practical life of an adult. The snake
symbolizes fear, danger, deceit, disguise and guile. It is symbolic
in the way that in the story of Adam and Eve ( from John Milton's
epic Paradise
Lost),
Satan comes in the form of a snake hidden behind flowers to cunningly
misguide Eve. The school
symbolizes training, nurturing, education, knowledge, upbringing etc.
Garden
represents the circle of life, harmony, peace, colours of life, a
paradise or the ideal state that everyone aspires for, a perfection
of nature and beauty, dominance of nature. Buildings/Factory
represents industrial revolution in today's world, man's struggle
against machines, advance of technology over human life, it can
signify order and discipline considering the way that the buildings
are arranged in order, a pattern, but order and discipline should be
in our lives. Globe
of the earth
signifies the passing time as it revolves. Crossroads
represents unexpected happenings and a choice between different
paths, just the way humans have chosen the path of destruction,
nuclear weapons, technology and material gains over the path of
morality and virtue. Fire
represents evil, wrongdoings, danger, damage, hell, and all the bad
deeds. It also represents jealousy, lust for power, money,
selfishness, deceit, materialism and mass consumerism.
In
the last paragraph the narrator is using the technique of rhetorical
questions. The narrator is actually showing a picture of modern life,
he is showing us the mirror. As opposed to the garden of life shown
earlier, it has been now taken over by technology, increasing human
population, materialism. Our life has become very fierce, demanding
and dangerous. We are living in a deceptive world where people have
forsaken their morality and humanity in order to leave others behind
in the mad race for power and fame. People will do anything to get
what they want, their eyes are filled with lust and greed. We are
caught up in trivial issues such as moneymaking and hording wealth in
our homes, we do not know what path we have chosen and where it will
lead to, we do not know where we're heading. There is a lack of
humanity and moral virtues. We have become very superficial and we
expect others to be the same way. We are now drawn against human
beings and our mind sees a potential threat in even our closest
relatives, we feel everyone is trying to put us down and get ahead of
us, or trick us into poverty. We can relate this idea to that In “The
Chief Guest” by Akhtar Jamal. There is a severe deterioration of
moral values in the society, a reversal or transition of values. The
narrator has tried to show us the consequences of such destruction;
what there was, what there is, and what will be if we do not mend our
ways.
Life
is passing in a split second, it is beyond our control, we are soon
able to accept this and adjust ourselves according to the demands of
the fast-paced world. Humans are resigned to destructive elements,
similar to our acceptance of the constructive elements in life.
“Half
a Day” by Naguib Mahfouz is an allegorical short story that
reflects the journey of life and the speed in which it begins and
ends. It also gives representation to stages and changes that occur
within a person during their time on Earth. “Half a Day”,
can only be fully understood through its symbolism and is not
intended to be interpreted literally. In order to fully
understand the reader must be able to comprehend that each part has a
greater meaning then the words that appear on the paper and that each
meaning is greater than the one before. In addition, Mahfouz
uses elaborate figurative and descriptive language, painting a vivid
picture and allowing the reader to be present in the moment.
Though
there are not many characters in this story, their importance is of
the utmost. They are emblematic as well, each having
additional meanings as well as their literal interpretation. His
father holding his hand could also represent the hand of God leading
him along a righteous path or ushering him in and out of life. The
mother admires her son quietly and from afar, leaving the task of
guiding a boy to manhood to her husband. The teacher is the
rule-maker, identified as a person. She keeps order and
punishes those who cannot or will not abide. His classmates
are all the people that he becomes acquainted with over time, females
that he has had relationship with and loved. However, not all
are good people nor do they all have the same opportunities,
prompting the decision making that all children must make on their
road to adulthood. The most central character is the boy himself
beginning his day as a young lad and progressing into teenager, young
man, middle age and finally an old man looking for his final
home.
This short story is deceitfully ironic because it is about a man that lives his entire life in the span of a day starting as a young boy and ending as an old man. Mahfouz is comparing life to his first day of school.
This short story is deceitfully ironic because it is about a man that lives his entire life in the span of a day starting as a young boy and ending as an old man. Mahfouz is comparing life to his first day of school.
Few
links are given for further analysis:
Questions:
- What kind of person is the narrator's father?
- At what point in the story does it become apparent that the story covers more than the narrator's first day in school? How does Mahfouz employ the journey motif in his narrative?
- What is the theme of the story?
- How is the fire at the end of the story significant? Why are the other activities recorded in the final paragraph important?Credit-Muneeza Rafiq
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)